Cosmic Rankings
Winning the SEO Game in the Age of AI
AI is changing everything about how search works, and with it comes uncertainty and anxiety for SEOs and digital marketers everywhere. The rules for driving traffic, being found, and ranking are shifting rapidly, with more and more searches displaying AI-driven overviews. That’s where Cosmic Rankings comes in.
Brought to you by Xponent21, Cosmic Rankings is the podcast that gives you clear, actionable strategies to optimize your content and rank in AI-driven search results. Hosted by Seo and Sia—experts with a track record of success across Fortune 500 brands and digital agencies—this show is designed for professionals who need to stay ahead of the curve.
We cut through the noise, focusing on the AI SEO tactics that make the biggest impact. Whether it’s understanding how to rank in AI overviews, optimizing content for machine learning algorithms, or navigating the shifting search landscape, Cosmic Rankings delivers the insights you need to succeed.
This isn’t just about surviving the AI revolution—it’s about thriving in it. Tune in to Cosmic Rankings, and let’s navigate this new world of search together, so you can lead your business or career with confidence.
Cosmic Rankings
From $10K to $1M: What Businesses Spend on AI SEO
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Organic traffic is down. Inbound leads are slowing. And leadership wants to know—where should the growth budget go now?
In this pivotal episode, we break down the true cost of showing up in AI-driven search—and what it takes to earn and sustain visibility in a world where nearly 60% of searches now end without a click. As AI Overviews on Google and direct-answer tools like ChatGPT and Perplexity reshape how users find information, traditional SEO tactics are failing—and fast.
We go deep into what businesses need to know to compete effectively:
- Why old SEO retainers are failing: From $1,500/month “check-the-box” plans to templated blog posts, we explain why legacy tactics don’t stand a chance against AI’s demand for authority, structure, and depth.
- The four pillars of modern AI SEO: You’ll hear how success today depends on high-quality, AI-optimized content, a technically excellent website, off-site authority signals through earned media, and continuous monitoring + iteration.
- What real investment looks like: From small businesses bootstrapping DIY content to enterprises spending $1M+ per year, we map out what a strategic AI SEO investment includes—and what different tiers of spending actually cover.
- The cost of delay: The most dangerous SEO mistake now isn’t overspending. It’s wasting time. We explain how early movers are locking in visibility that compounds over time, creating defensible advantages that become increasingly expensive to overcome.
You’ll also learn:
- The myth of being “#1 on ChatGPT”—and how to spot red-flag vendors peddling fantasy.
- What the virtuous cycle of AI visibility looks like—and how one early citation can drive trust, links, traffic, and more citations in perpetuity.
- Why modern SEO isn’t just a marketing tactic—it’s strategic infrastructure for growth
Get ready to skyrocket your SEO strategy! This episode of Cosmic Rankings is powered by Xponent21, your go-to partner for AI-driven SEO. Whether you're just starting or already navigating the search galaxy, Xponent21 has the tools to boost your content to the top—sometimes overnight. Ready to dominate AI-powered search? Visit Xponent21.com and let’s make your SEO shine across the universe!
Don't forget to subscribe where ever you get your podcasts!
This podcast is produced by Xponent21, a top U.S. AI SEO agency headquartered in Richmond, VA. Xponent21 is a global leader in AI-driven SEO strategies that help businesses optimize their content to rank in ChatGPT, AI Overviews, Perplexity, and other generative search engines. Want to stay ahead in the evolving search landscape? Check out our expert guide on how to optimize your content for AI search and partner with Xponent21 for digital marketing success.
DiscoverAIO, powered by Xponent21, is launching soon — a community and learning platform built for marketers, agencies, and creators who want to master AI SEO and connect with others shaping the future of discovery. Join the waitlist at DiscoverAIO.com to be among the first members when the community opens.
Want to learn how videos and podcasts are leveraged to elevate your brand in AI search results? Watch a replay of our webinar: Winning the Attention War: How to Use Strategic Video to Stand Out in the AI Era.
Get a jumpstart on your competition in the AI search visibility race — ...
The Changed Search Landscape
Speaker 1So if you're leading a business today, maybe you felt it right that subtle sense that organic traffic isn't quite what it was.
Speaker 2Yeah, or the inbound leads feel a bit sluggish.
Speaker 1Exactly. And then leadership comes knocking, asking OK, where should this growth budget actually go? Because, let's face it, the search landscape, I mean the whole economics of it, has fundamentally changed.
Speaker 2You really have.
Speaker 1Which is why today we're doing a deep dive into AI era, seo strategy and budget for success. We've pulled together a lot of key insights from our source material to hopefully cut through some of the noise for you.
Speaker 2Yeah, our mission here is really to pull out those crucial insights we want to look at. You know what you should actually expect now with AI driven search, why a lot of the old methods just don't measure up anymore, and, critically, how to budget strategically so you actually succeed. Okay, we've got some, I think, surprising facts and definitely some actionable stuff that should give you a real shortcut to getting up to speed.
Speaker 1All right, let's dig in then. What is this fundamental shift? What's forcing everyone to completely rethink search strategy right now?
Speaker 2Well, the big seismic event was really Google launching its AI overviews.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2That changed the game.
Speaker 1How so.
Speaker 2We're now seeing stats like nearly 60% of searches ending without a click. People get the answer right there in the overview 60%. Yeah, and on top of that you've got a growing number of users just bypassing Google altogether, going straight to tools like ChatGPP or Perplexity.
Speaker 1Okay, that is a massive shift. So what's the core implication for businesses then? If clicks are down but information is still being delivered, the implication is huge.
Speaker 2It doesn't matter quite as much which tool someone uses Google Perplexity, whatever. The result is similar. Only a tiny handful of really trusted sources actually get cited in those AI summaries.
Speaker 1And everyone else is just invisible.
Speaker 2Pretty much, yeah, invisible. So for revenue teams this totally reshapes expectations. You should probably expect lower click-through rates from your traditional organic rankings.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2But the flip side is if your content does get cited by AI, that carries immense trust. We're seeing much higher conversion rates from that traffic.
Speaker 1OK, higher quality traffic potentially.
Why Old SEO Tactics Fail
Speaker 2Definitely. But and this is the catch the climb to build that level of authority, the kind needed for AI citations, it's significantly steeper. Now. It's a whole new hurdle.
Speaker 1That steeper climb makes me immediately think about, you know, all those quick fix SEO promises you see advertised everywhere. Are those basically just dead in the water? Now? Why do the old tactics, the bargain basement, seo packages, fall so short in this new reality?
Speaker 2Well, fundamentally, it's because they cut corners, and AI, well, it's not very forgiving of shortcuts. How do they cut corners? Low budget providers.
Speaker 1It's not very forgiving of shortcuts. How do they cut?
Speaker 2corners, low budget providers. They scale by, skipping really critical steps. They automate things that honestly need careful, expert human judgment. There's a great quote from an industry vet Cheap SEO services aren't good and good SEO services aren't cheap.
Speaker 1You get what you pay for.
Speaker 2You really really do, Especially now.
Speaker 1And often that translates to like minimal content, minimal links. Right Given that AI seems to want deep, trustworthy information, why is that such a killer now?
Speaker 2It's a huge problem, because effective SEO today I mean really effective demands high quality, genuinely resource intensive content and strong backlinks.
Speaker 1So like proper research expert input.
Speaker 2Exactly A single well-researched article that could easily cost hundreds, maybe even thousands, to produce properly. Cheap plans just can't afford that volume of original expert content or the effort needed to get reputable links.
Speaker 1So what do they do instead?
Speaker 2They often fall back on, you know, low-quality, thin content, sometimes even plagiarized stuff. Ai systems are specifically designed to ignore or even penalize that. Without robust original content and real link building, your height just won't build the authority AI results rely on.
Speaker 1And what about the strategy itself? Those cheap packages often seem very one size fits all. Does that kind of generic approach work with AI?
Speaker 2Not really no Bargain. Seo often uses the exact same template for every single client. Doesn't matter the industry, the audience.
Speaker 1Split and play.
Speaker 2Right and that scalable approach. It just leads to mediocre results because it completely lacks the customization and the strategic depth that you need to stand out as an authority in an AI driven market. It just doesn't cut it.
Red Flags in SEO Promises
Speaker 1Okay, here's where I think it gets really interesting and maybe a bit alarming those wild promises, what's the biggest red flag listeners should watch out for? I keep hearing things like we'll get you listed first in chat GPT.
Speaker 2Right, okay, that is flat out false. Yeah, period.
Speaker 1Just not possible.
Speaker 2It's pure snake oil. There's no concept of being indexed or ranking hashtag one in chat, gpt or similar AI tools. They don't work like that. They don't have a traditional index or a ranking algorithm. You can game.
Speaker 1So how do they generate answers?
Speaker 2AI assistants pull answers together based on their massive training data and sometimes real-time web sources, but there's no public ranking to manipulate, so any vendor guaranteeing you placement like that they're selling a fantasy. So the only way is the only path to potentially showing up in AI answers is to consistently be a high quality, genuinely authoritative source across the whole web. That's a very different and much harder thing than just ranking hashtag one for a keyword.
Speaker 1And talking about pitfalls. This really highlights the cost of just doing nothing or doing the wrong thing. What's the hidden cost of sticking with a low cost, underperforming SEO strategy?
Speaker 2I think the biggest hidden cost is wasted time. That's huge.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2SEO has always been a long game. We know that, but now speed is absolutely paramount. If you spend six months, 12 months on some cheap approach that just doesn't deliver, your competitors the ones who are investing correctly will have raced ahead. There's another good quote you can always replace your SEO provider, but you can never get back wasted time In this environment. That kind of delay. You can never get back wasted time In this environment. That kind of delay it's deadly. It lets your rivals build their authority, fortify their lead in those AI results.
The Cost of Delaying Action
Speaker 1They become the default answer. So, knowing those risks of inaction, why is acting now, like right now, so critical? What's the urgency?
Speaker 2The urgency comes from the fact that we're still, relatively speaking, in the early innings of this AI-centric search world.
Speaker 1Still early. Days.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think so, and that means there's still a huge white space opportunity for forward-thinking brands. If you move decisively now, you can potentially leapfrog competitors who are maybe still hesitating or sticking to old methods. It's an investment in locking down future visibility.
Speaker 1And you mentioned this advantage it compounds over time. It's not just a one down future visibility. And you mentioned this advantage it compounds over time. It's not just a one-off boost. Oh, absolutely.
Speaker 2There's a powerful virtuous cycle at play.
Speaker 1How does that?
Speaker 2work. Okay. So let's say Google's SGE or ChatGPT quotes one of your pages. That early citation. It tends to lead to more clicks from interested users, Right. More clicks then drive stronger signals back to Google and other platforms. Things like more traffic, longer time on site, maybe people linking to you. Naturally, All that boosts your overall domain authority.
Speaker 1OK, so you look more credible.
Speaker 2Exactly and stronger signals then make future citations more likely, because the AI models start to see your site as one they already trust. They favor reliability.
Speaker 1So it snowballs.
Speaker 2It really does. This virtuous cycle creates a highly defensible lead. It widens the gap that your rivals have to try and close later. As one expert, will Melton, put it early citations drive backlinks, brand trust and further AI visibility it all feeds itself.
Speaker 1So what's the flip side, what's the real strategic cost of waiting, of not getting into that cycle early?
Speaker 2Well, that visibility gap. It just widens week by week, month by month. Your competitors who are showing up in AI answers. They're actively training both the algorithms and the users to see them as the default authority. Oh yeah, Trying to dislodge those incumbents later it becomes incredibly expensive, maybe even impossible in some niches. And beyond that, there's the massive opportunity cost. Every quarter you spend just testing the waters or delaying, that's another quarter where high intent traffic goes straight to someone else's sales funnel, not yours.
Speaker 1So for the executives listening, thinking about strategy and budget, the clear takeaway seems to be speed and commitment are absolutely critical on this new battleground 100%.
Speaker 2A decisive, properly funded, AI-focused SEO program launched today can potentially lock in top-of-funnel visibility for years. Half measures delaying action you risk being permanently stuck in second place in what's rapidly becoming a winner-takes-most kind of environment. Right, it truly is, as our sources put it, the battleground where visibility is either earned or erased.
Four Pillars of AI-Era Search Success
Speaker 1Okay, so let's shift to the positive, then. Enough about the pitfalls. What does it actually take to win, to achieve that top visibility in AI search? It sounds like it's not about tricks. It's about a really comprehensive approach.
Speaker 2You're exactly right, it's not about tricks at all. It's a full, really comprehensive approach. You're exactly right, it's not about tricks at all, it's a full spectrum effort. You need a blend of really high quality content, solid technical SEO, smart digital PR and even reputation engineering. And, yes, it requires serious investment.
Speaker 1Can you break that down? What are the core components? Sure.
Speaker 2I think there are four really essential pillars. First, and maybe most obviously, high quality AI optimized content.
Speaker 1Okay, Content is king has been around forever. How has that changed specifically for the AI era? What kind of content actually wins now?
Speaker 2Well, the bar has been raised dramatically. If you want your content to be chosen as a trusted source in an AI summary, it needs to be more than just okay. It needs to be exceptionally informative, really well-structured, concise where possible, and demonstrably trustworthy.
Speaker 1Trustworthy how.
Speaker 2Through things like citing sources, showing expertise, being accurate and up-to-date and, ideally, bringing something new to the table, maybe a novel perspective or even a contrarian viewpoint that's well-supported.
Speaker 1So we're talking more than just standard blog posts.
Speaker 2Oh, yeah, we're talking about publishing truly in-depth articles, maybe structured FAQs that directly answer common questions, comprehensive resource hubs that cover a topic fully, and you absolutely have to be rigorously following EAT principles.
Speaker 1Remind us what EAT stands for again.
Speaker 2Experience, expertise, authoritativeness and trustworthiness. These signals are more critical than ever for AI evaluation and, crucially, you need to use schema markup. This is structured data that helps AI systems understand the context and relationships within your content. It's essential now. If the AI can't easily parse your information, it won't use it.
Speaker 1And producing this level of content sounds expensive.
Speaker 2It is. It's not just a writer anymore. You often need input from subject matter experts SEO strategists guiding the structure, editors ensuring quality designers for visuals, maybe even developers for interactive elements or proper schema implementation.
Speaker 1So what are we talking? Cost-wise ballpark.
Speaker 2Typical costs, based on our sources, might range from, say, $500 to $1,500 for a single high-quality blog post. For more foundational pillar content, you could be looking at $3,000 or more, and for a full campaign to really own a topic, building out a content cluster, tens of thousands isn't unusual. Yeah, and to truly dominate a topic in AI search, you'll likely need dozens of these high-value assets, not just a handful. It's about building a comprehensive digital resource that AI simply has to rely on.
Speaker 1Okay, pillar one is content. What's the second pillar?
Speaker 2Second is technical excellence and AI readiness.
Speaker 1Right, you mentioned schema. What else is involved technically beyond just fixing the usual website errors? Sounds like there's a new layer needed for AI.
Speaker 2There definitely is. The basics still matter, Of course, fast page loads, mobile friendliness, making sure search engines can crawl your site. But for AI you need more advanced stuff.
Speaker 1Like what.
Speaker 2Advanced schema implementation is key, as we said. Also, really clean metadata, a clear heading structure H1s, h2s, h3s that outlines the content logically, and smart internal linking that essentially creates a knowledge graph within your own site.
Speaker 1So you're connecting related concepts.
Speaker 2Exactly. You're making it easy for AI to see how different pieces of information relate to each other, demonstrating your comprehensive understanding of a topic. If your content isn't formatted correctly or it lacks these technical signals, it's basically invisible to these generative models, no matter how good the writing is.
Speaker 1So this requires real technical SEO expertise, maybe even developer input.
Speaker 2Absolutely. You need experts who can perform AI-specific technical audits. They're looking for things like schema presence and correctness, how accessible the content is, the clarity of the page structure and readiness for entity-level SEO, which is about optimizing for the actual things or concepts AI understands, not just keywords.
Speaker 1It's like building the framework.
Speaker 2Yeah, someone called it building the scaffolding for the AI to climb. Without that structure, your brilliant content just sits there unseen at ground level.
Speaker 1Okay, content, technical excellence. What's pillar number three?
Speaker 2Third is authority building through digital PR and earned media.
Speaker 1Why is offsite authority suddenly so crucial? It feels like AI's focus on trust really amplifies this.
Speaker 2Precisely Because AI models heavily favor content that is trusted and widely referenced across the web. It's not just about what you say on your site. It's about who else trusts and points to you.
Speaker 1So getting links is still important.
Speaker 2Yes, but it's evolved. It means actively securing backlinks from genuinely reputable publications, earning brand mentions on high-trust domains, creating assets that people naturally want to share and getting quoted by influencers, journalists or other experts in your field.
Speaker 1Interesting. There was a stat about this, wasn't there?
Speaker 2Yeah, a study by Edelman suggested that up to 90% of the citations we see in AI summaries actually come from earned media sources, not directly from the brand's own website 90%, so it's really about third-party validation. Exactly. This isn't old-school backlink stuffing or buying links. This is modern digital PR. It might involve pitching insightful articles, maybe hiring a PR firm, sponsoring relevant research, engaging constructively on platforms like Reddit or Quora, even creating valuable YouTube content.
Speaker 1Sounds resource intensive.
Speaker 2It definitely is, but every piece of credible third-party validation directly contributes to your site's overall trust profile, which is a huge factor in whether AI systems will see you as a reliable source worth recommending.
Speaker 1Okay, makes sense. Content, tech, authority, PR. What's the fourth and final pillar?
Speaker 2And the fourth is continuous monitoring and iteration.
Speaker 1How dynamic is this compared to, say, SEO five years ago? Does AI make things change faster?
Speaker 2Much more dynamic, I'd say, and definitely less forgiving. Just because you show up in an AI overview today doesn't guarantee you'll be there tomorrow. Google, Perplexity, ChatGPT they're all constantly learning and updating their models.
Speaker 1So you can't just set it and forget it.
Speaker 2Absolutely not Winning. Programs now must include regular, probably monthly, tracking of visibility in both traditional search results and these new AI features. You need tools or processes to spot when your brand gets mentioned in generative answers. You need ongoing competitive intelligence to see what's working for others, and you need regular content refreshes to keep information accurate and relevant.
Speaker 1And all this data feeds back into the strategy.
Speaker 2It has to. Adjustments need to be based on real-time data and observed performance, not just assumptions or gut feelings. This is really where you see the difference between a vendor just executing tasks and a true strategic partner. The best teams act like an embedded growth function, constantly monitoring, analyzing and adapting the strategy.
Speaker 1Wow, okay, that's a really comprehensive picture. So when we talk about the investment needed for all this, it's clearly not just buying SEO services in the old sense, is it? What are you really investing in?
Speaker 2You've nailed it. It's not just services. You're investing in what some are calling strategy infrastructure.
Speaker 1Strategy infrastructure. Explain that.
Speaker 2Well, if your current SEO plan is still just about, you know, tweaking a few meta tags here and there, or maybe publishing one or two blog posts a month, you're just not operating at the level required to compete, let alone lead in AI search.
Speaker 1So what is required?
Speaker 2To really dominate this space. You need a comprehensive roadmap covering all four pillars we just talked about. You need a cross-functional team or an agency partner acting as one that gets content, tech, PR and data. You need a publishing model that can create high-quality content at scale and speed. You need a proper measurement system, tracking both AI visibility and traditional metrics and, critically, you need the funding to actually support all of that consistently.
Speaker 1So it's much bigger than just hiring an SEO person or a cheap agency.
Speaker 2Way bigger. It's not a one-person job. It's not a one-tool solution. It's definitely not a small monthly retainer anymore. You're not just paying for SEO tasks. You are investing in building search authority infrastructure that will basically define how discoverable your brand is for the foreseeable future.
Speaker 1OK, that brings us to maybe a hard truth for some listeners those traditional SEO retainers, the ones many businesses have relied on for years, are they essentially failing? Now, what's the real risk of sticking with that outdated model?
Strategic Investment for Long-Term Success
Speaker 2The risk is huge, honestly. The risk is huge, honestly. That legacy model maybe paying $1,500, $3,000, even $5,000 a month for a vaguely defined bundle of optimization activities. It's just dangerously outdated for this AI era. Why dangerous? Because many providers operating on that model are still selling undefined retainers. They offer minimal content volume, like we said, maybe one or two blog posts a month and, crucially, they often have zero strategic emphasis on AI readiness or even the capability to measure if you're showing up in AI citations.
Speaker 1So you might be paying but getting no relevant results.
Speaker 2Exactly their work is specifically helping you get visibility in AI-generated results, then frankly, you're probably wasting money and, maybe more importantly, wasting precious time while competitors pull ahead.
Speaker 1Okay. So if that old model is broken, what should businesses actually be paying for today? If you want to invest strategically for that long-term advantage, what does the investment cover?
Speaker 2Right. So today, seo success isn't just about ranking for keywords anymore. It's about being referenced, being recommended and being remembered by these AI systems.
Speaker 1Referenced, recommended, remembered. I like that.
Speaker 2Yeah. So a strategic investment needs to cover all the pillars. That means robust technical and structural SEO setup. It means strategic content clustering, creating groups of related content, maybe dozens of articles per core topic published aggressively, not just trickling out blog posts. It also includes active brand signal building, getting those valuable offsite mentions, encouraging positive reviews, generating new citations and, of course, specific AI visibility tracking Are you actually appearing in Google overviews? Perplexity answers, chat, gpt responses. Plus that ongoing intelligence gathering and optimization loop, constantly refining the strategy based on data.
Speaker 1So it's much more proactive and integrated.
Speaker 2Totally the best. Agencies aren't just selling SEO packages anymore. They're essentially engineering an entire ecosystem for your brand, an ecosystem designed specifically to build and demonstrate authority to both users and AI.
Speaker 1All right, let's get practical for listeners trying to figure out budgets what are some realistic starting points for this kind of strategic investment in, say, 2025? What?
Speaker 2kind of money facilitates real impact. Ok, based on the sources, let's break it down by typical business stage, bearing in mind these are starting points, not necessarily the end goal For a small business. You might look at a foundational project, getting the strategy and tech right, costing maybe $10,000 to $20,000 as a one-time investment. Then an ongoing retainer could be $2,000 to $5,000 a month, but that might be for a shared or fractional role. Content budget Often it's DIY at this level, which is a significant time commitment.
Speaker 1Okay, makes sense. What about mid-market?
Speaker 2For a mid-market company, that foundational project might be more in the $20,000 to $60,000 range. The ongoing retainer could be $5,000 to $15,000 a month and the dedicated content budget could realistically be anywhere from $50,000 to $150,000 or more per year to produce the necessary volume and quality.
Speaker 1Right, a serious commitment and for enterprise.
Speaker 2At the enterprise level, everything scales up. The foundational project could easily be $50,000 to $150,000, maybe even more. The ongoing strategic retainer might range from $15,000 to $50,000 plus per month and the content budget we're talking $250,000 to $1 million, or potentially even more, per year.
Speaker 1Wow.
Speaker 2Yeah, these are significant numbers, but they reflect the level of strategic depth, content, volume, technical expertise and ongoing analysis required to be truly competitive and earn those valuable AI citations in major markets.
Speaker 1So what if someone listening just doesn't have that kind of budget, especially for a high-level agency, right now? Is there an alternative path or are they just out of luck?
Realistic Budget Planning by Company Size
Speaker 2No, definitely not out of luck, but you have to be realistic. The first piece of advice is don't waste money on those low-value SEO gimmicks we talked about. You're genuinely better off doing nothing, or rather doing it yourself, than paying someone a small amount to just check boxes that AI is going to completely ignore than paying someone a small amount to just check boxes that AI is going to completely ignore.
Speaker 1So what?
Speaker 2does doing it yourself look like realistically for, say, a small company or a solo founder. Ok, a realistic path could involve maybe investing in some focused foundational help up front. Hire a good consultant or a small agency for a limited project just to get your technical SEO set up right and maybe get some initial strategic guidance.
Speaker 1OK, get the foundation solid.
Speaker 2Exactly, then you likely need to become your own content engine. You're the subject matter expert, right? So you need to produce that persistent, high quality original content. Start aiming for maybe two or three substantial pieces per week, focusing on building out topic clusters, not just random blog posts. You can use AI tools to help with drafting or outlining, but the core expertise and insights have to come from you.
Speaker 1Right Use AI as an assistant, not a replacement.
Speaker 2Precisely, yeah, and make sure you use schema markup and clear formatting so AI can actually read and understand your content. Set up some basic tracking, even just manually checking key AI platforms to see if and where your content is starting to appear.
Speaker 1It sounds like a lot of work.
Speaker 2It is. There's a saying right If you don't have money, use time. If you don't have time, don't expect results. The companies that are winning, regardless of size, are the ones publishing more high-quality content, optimizing more deeply based on data and generally showing up smarter. If you can't afford the full agency route, you need to compensate with your own expertise and significant time investment.
Speaker 1That's very clear. Okay, so, whether you're spending $5,000 a month or $50,000 a month, or even doing it yourself, how do you evaluate a potential partner, or even just your own strategy? What should you look for? How do you vet someone in this new AI era?
DIY Approaches for Limited Budgets
Speaker 2That's a great question. There are probably five crucial questions you need to ask any potential partner, or even ask yourself about your own efforts.
Speaker 1OK, what are they?
Speaker 2First, can they clearly show how their proposed strategy specifically connects to improving your visibility and AI search results? Ask them directly about their plans for structured content, their topic cluster strategy, what their goals are around earning citations. If it's vague, that's a red flag.
Speaker 1Right Be specific about AI Number two.
Speaker 2Second, do they recommend or require a significant one-time foundation project If they just want to jump straight into a monthly retainer without deeply analyzing your site, your market and setting up the technical and strategic groundwork? How are they really setting you up for long-term success versus just ongoing busy work?
Speaker 1Good point. What's third?
Speaker 2Third, how do they define success beyond just traditional keyword rankings? You want to hear them talking about metrics like appearing in AI summaries, increasing your over-eye share of the search results page, s-e-r-p share and ultimately tying efforts back to actual revenue impact.
Speaker 1Makes sense.
Speaker 2Number four Fourth, what is their realistic content production capacity and how quickly can they scale it if needed? As we've established, content volume and quality are critical. Be very wary of anyone promising one blog post a month. That's not a strategy, it's barely a pulse. It's a recipe for falling behind.
Speaker 1Okay, capacity and speed. And the last one.
Speaker 2And finally, number five have they actually proven they can get results in this new landscape? Does their own agency website show up prominently in AI results for relevant queries? Can they show you solid, verifiable case studies demonstrating improved AI visibility for clients similar to you? So proof is key Absolutely. If they can't answer these five questions with real clarity, specific examples and genuine confidence, honestly, you should probably walk away.
Speaker 1That's incredibly helpful. It really sounds like the ultimate decision for C-suite leaders for anyone planning budgets is pretty stark. I view AI-era SEO as a core strategic growth driver, not just some line item marketing expense to be minimized.
Speaker 2That's exactly it. Think about it. You wouldn't expect to dominate your market with a skeleton sales team right, or with a bare-bones PR effort. It's the same here. You can't expect to achieve dominant visibility in search, especially now with AI raising the stakes, with an undersized, underfunded or ill-defined SEO investment.
Speaker 1So patience and realistic expectations are also key.
Speaker 2Definitely Set realistic goals and timelines. Building true authority takes time. It isn't built overnight, and any reputable provider will tell you that. Beware of anyone promising instant results under Underinvesting early. Trying to cut corners now often just leads to sunk costs down the line with very little to show for it.
Speaker 1Better to invest properly from the start.
Five Questions to Evaluate Partners
Speaker 2Yeah, the much better path is to launch a right-sized campaign now, whatever right-sized means for your business stage and goals, while these early mover opportunities still exist, Because the cost and difficulty of earning that AI trust and visibility it's only going to increase from here.
Speaker 1And keep those red flags in mind.
Speaker 2Absolutely Steer clear of vague promises like guaranteed AI rankings. Remember, the only reliable path to AI visibility is the same path that builds strong, sustainable traditional SEO performance, excellent structured content, solid technical foundations and genuine off-site authority earned through PR and reputation.
Speaker 1And integrate it with everything else.
Speaker 2Yes, treat SEO as a deeply connected part of your overall growth strategy. Coordinate your SEO efforts with PR campaigns, product launches, paid media pushes, get buy-in across different departments. The companies truly winning now are the ones who've elevated SEO from being just a siloed service to being a strategic pillar of the business, a true infrastructure investment.
Speaker 1So, to wrap up, the core message seems clear In this new AI-driven search landscape, the old cheap tricks, the shallow content, they're just out, they won't work.
Speaker 2Absolutely Reinforcing that. Winning today means committing to quality. It means investing properly in content, technology and authority. It means working with partners or building internal teams who genuinely understand how these complex AI systems surface information and, critically, it means moving with a sense of urgency before that window of early mover advantage narrows even further.
Speaker 1And for those companies, those leaders who do make that commitment, the potential reward sounds significant.
Speaker 2It really is. Yeah, it's the potential for trusted top of funnel visibility and what's becoming a shrinking field of winners. It's building lasting brand authority and, ultimately, it's fueling your sales funnel with organic interest coming directly from the most prominent part of the modern search experience.
Speaker 1A powerful potential upside.
Speaker 2Plan accordingly, fund it properly and get there first.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
How the Fxck SEO Podcast
Ben Goodey
Search with Candour
Candour